From Costco's Triumph to Tops Club's Trials – A Comparative Study of Retail Strategies in Asia
US wholesale giant found success across borders in Asian markets despite local competition. However, Tops Club, from the giant Thai conglomerate, Central Group struggled in the local markets. What are some lessons that can be learned?
At a glance
Industry
Wholesale Retail
Company Focus
Costco, Tops Club
Market Focus
Asia
Thailand, Japan, Taiwan
Abstract
Costco, the American giant, succeeded significantly in Asian markets like Japan and Taiwan by effectively adapting its core strategy. This included understanding local preferences, leveraging direct trade with manufacturers, and implementing a "treasure hunt" shopping experience. Tops Club, a Thai venture, faced challenges due to the market's unfamiliarity with membership fees, perceived high pricing, and a focus on exclusivity that clashed with the traditional bargain-hunting aspect of wholesale shopping. Despite initial interest, Tops Club struggled to gain traction and closed its physical stores later.
This case study analyzes the contrasting fortunes of Costco and Tops Club in the Asian wholesale retail market. It underscores the critical importance of market research, cultural sensitivity, and adaptable business strategies for success in this dynamic landscape.
All rights reserved. © 2025 Nikkei Business Lab Asia. No part of this publication may be copied, stored, or transmitted in any form. Copying or posting is an infringement of copyright.
Disclaimers:
(1) Regarding Case Study Content: This case study is based mainly on secondary data and analysis of publicly available information unless otherwise stated, and is intended solely for educational purposes. Any opinions expressed by the author(s) are designed to facilitate learning discussion and do not serve to illustrate the effectiveness of the company. Additionally, banner images and logos used in the case study are intended for visualization in an educational setting and it is not used to represent or brand the company. For any dispute regarding the content and usage of images and logos, please contact the team.
(2) Regarding University Affiliation and Titles of Authors: The university affiliation and titles of author(s) seen in the case study is based on their affiliation and title during the time of publication. It may or may not represent the current status of said author(s).