Internal Noise - The Great Disruptor!

Internal noise in communications disrupts even the best strategies. This dual case study takes Katinat and Bphone as prime examples, where internal noise had caused muddled messages and unclear roles, resulting in strategic drift.

Dr. Kenny Guan Cheng TEOH | Sunway Univesity
Kim Thanh LE | Nikkei BizRuptors

Published On 19 Dec 2024

Last Updated On 19 Dec 2024

At a glance

Country

Vietnam

Launched

Katinat: 2016 Bphone: 2015

Sector

Katinat: Food & Beverage Bphone: Digital Technology

Abstract

Even the most well-intentioned business strategies can fail when internal communication breaks down. This case study explores the concept of internal noise and its role in creating strategic drift through the experiences of two prominent Vietnamese companies: Katinat, a fast-growing food and beverage chain, and BKAV, the technology company behind the smartphone brand Bphone. Both organizations experienced significant reputational damage when internal misalignment distorted the messages they communicated to the public.

In Katinat’s case, a charitable fundraising campaign intended to support victims of Typhoon Yagi was perceived as opportunistic and insensitive, triggering widespread public criticism. In contrast, BKAV’s launch of Bphone suffered from excessive promotional claims that failed to match the product’s actual performance, resulting in customer disappointment and long-term reputational challenges. Although operating in different industries, both cases demonstrate how poorly aligned internal objectives, ambiguous communication, and ineffective coordination can undermine strategic intent and damage stakeholder trust.

The case further examines how internal noise manifests through cognitive dissonance, conflicting directives, unclear responsibilities, and leadership-driven messaging. It also explores how these challenges become more pronounced in high-context cultures such as Vietnam, where communication often relies on implicit assumptions, hierarchy, and shared understanding. Learners are invited to evaluate the relationship between organizational communication and strategic execution, analyze the causes of communication breakdowns, and develop approaches to strengthening message alignment, crisis management, and stakeholder trust in complex business environments.


Key Topics: Internal Noise in Organizations, Strategic Drift and Execution Failure, Organizational Communication, Crisis Communication Management, Reputation and Brand Management, High-Context Culture and Business Communication, Stakeholder Trust and Public Perception, Leadership Communication, Corporate Crisis Response, Strategic Alignment and Organizational Behavior

 


 

Cover photo by Luke Jones on Unsplash

All rights reserved. © 2026 Nikkei Business Lab Asia. No part of this publication may be copied, stored, or transmitted in any form. Copying or posting is an infringement of copyright.

Disclaimers:

(1) Regarding Case Study Content: This case study is based mainly on secondary data and analysis of publicly available information unless otherwise stated, and is intended solely for educational purposes. Any opinions expressed by the author(s) are designed to facilitate learning discussion and do not serve to illustrate the effectiveness of the company. Additionally, banner images and logos used in the case study are intended for visualization in an educational setting and it is not used to represent or brand the company. For any dispute regarding the content and usage of images and logos, please contact the team.

(2) Regarding University Affiliation and Titles of Authors: The university affiliation and titles of author(s) seen in the case study is based on their affiliation and title during the time of publication. It may or may not represent the current status of said author(s).

Related Case Studies

From Facebook to Meta - Rebranding or Dealing with Ethical Dilemmas?

From Facebook to Meta - Rebranding or Dealing with Ethical Dilemmas?

Cross-Cultural Communication – Navigating Product Design in a Global-Local Context

Cross-Cultural Communication – Navigating Product Design in a Global-Local Context

Reimagining the Cat – What Jaguar's Rebrand Can Teach Us

Reimagining the Cat – What Jaguar's Rebrand Can Teach Us

Subscribe to our BizRupted E-Letters

cs@nikkeibizruptors.com
Nikkei Business Lab Asia Ltd.No. 8 T One Building, 17th Fl, Sukhumvit soi 40, Sukhumvit Road, Phra Khanong, Khlong Toei, Bangkok 10110, Thailand